Offering exclusive content not available on Pornhub.
If you like her, and I'm assuming you do, I would suggest you continue the relationship and see how things pan out.
Interestingly, my parents felt the same way about him. Not every LDS person does, unfortunately.
Give yourself some credit for being attracted to the good side of the Force. If you have tended to straddle the line between light and dark in the past, or have been a partier, expect to make some changes for this relationship, and expect certain things from your new crush.